Chapter 39 He recognized that co continuing the argument with this woman would only push him to the brink of rage , yet he obviously couldn't resort to physical violence to release his frustration Ultimately , he stoned out , slamming the door with an enraged expression on his face . Much later , Giselle stepped into the bathroom to take a shower , As the hot water cascaded over her , soothing her body and mind , she couldn't shake Donovan's recent words from her thoughts . It appeared that , even after the scandalous video incident at the engagement party , he might not be truly ending the marriage alliance with Anne . It was delayed for the time being . To him , she was never more than a bedroom accessory . He was indifferent to the truth about her recent incident at the river or the harsh treatment she received from the He family . It she had truly died , he would have pretended to be sad for a few days before swiftly moving on to another woma Belecting on these better truths , Giselle inhaled deeply and started devising her next strategy . The following day marked Tony's birthday . Gulle had never made it a point to celebrate the birthdays of her despicable father . However , today she intentionally went to the mall , thoughtfully chose a birthday present , and wrapped it . When dinner time arrived , she hailed a taxi to the Holt residence . After an hour , she reached the villa's gate , gift in hand , and confidently walked into the living room . The butler and maid both halted in unison upon her entrance , casing their tasks and staring at her as if she were a specter . As she entered the living room and moved toward the couch , the Holts were even more shocked when they laid eyes on br " Giselle ? " Tony was the first to rise and approach tier , stumbling over his words , " You … Is it really you ? Did you return ? What … What's happening ? " Rence quickly stood up as well , her eyes wide and her mouth open in disbelief , her face reflecting , sheer panic om the opposite side , as Anne was malding her way down the stairs , she stopped abruptly midway when she saw her . Her hands and feet quivered slightly , unable to comprehend what she was witnessing The police had informed this family as the next of kin to view the scene where Giselle's car had plunged into the river . They had seen the retrieved wreckage themselves and listened to experts explain that Giselle's body might have been swept into the river or trapped at the lake's bottom , making it unlikely to resurface . Inshom , her chances of survival were deemed nonexistent . They had come to terms with her death , even going so far as to hire a priest from the local church for a memorial service at the site . In front of the police , they wept and insisted on retrieving her remains . Vel , in private , the family nearly celebrated with a feast , They used Tony's 53rd birthday as an excuse to set up a lavish spread of live seafood and rich meats , leping the maids busy with preparations Giselle smirked with scam . " It's been seven days since my memorial service . I've returned to see my family , especially my beloved father . I didn't forget it's your birthday today . " Tony's face went pale at her remark . As an experienced doctor who had witnessed numerous deaths in the hospital , he was unfazed by Giselle's presence . He knew " diselle , as long as you're safe … It's fine as long as you're okay , " Tony said never got into that car and never ended up in the He was clearly upset , even extending his hand to touch her shoulder " Where have you been all this time ? Youn river , did you ? selle couldn't stand Tory sincer look , she moved right in front of Renee and sneered " Besire , the assassin you hid was obviously a novice . Allt - and - in without ensuring I was actually dead ? It seems like your victory party is pointless . " " You .. Wut oneantii are you talking about ? " Still reeling from Giselle's unexpected retum , Renee w was in taken aback that she found it hard to keep her cool " No matter how much I might dislike you , I would never try to end your life ! When we heard you drove to the river , your father and I were in a panic . We've been demanding answers from the police and searching for you every single day . " " save " Giselle interid with scot " There's no need to explain , Renee . I understand . You both care about me so much . That's exactly why I'm here today , to celebrate dad's birthday , " She extended the glit box toward Tony . " Uson , Dad Openit and see the surprise I've bluught for you