Emma nodded , overwhelmed by gratitude . For the first time in days , she felt a glimmer of peace and hope . The dinner began on a lighthearted note . During the meal , grandpa , with his surprisingly sharp sense of humor , began his usual teasing . So , Emma , he said with a sly smile , when do you plan to give me a great grandchild ? 1/3 A Night to Remember +25 BONUS Emma froze , the fork halfway to her mouth . Her cheeks flushed a deep red as she looked to David for rescue . David , ever the mischievous one , leaned back in his chair with a smirk . Thats entirely up to Emma , Grandfather . Im more than ready to cooperate . Emma shot him a glare , her face growing impossibly redder as the grandfather let out a hearty laugh . The teasing broke through the tension that had been lingering in the air , and for a moment , Emma allowed herself to laugh too. The worries of the past few days seemed to fade into the background, replaced by the warmth of family and good humor . The lighthearted atmosphere was abruptly shattered by the arrival of the housekeeper . She entered hesitantly , her posture tense as she turned to grandpa . Sir , I apologize for the interruption , but … She glanced nervously at Emma before continuing . Theres someone here to see you . The grandfather frowned , clearly displeased . I wasnt expecting anyone . Who is it ? The housekeeper glanced at Emma again , making her feel this bad premonition that something was about to go very wrong . Its Miss Allison , the housekeeper replied softly . Emmas heart sank , a sense of foreboding washing over her . The grandfathers expression darkened . Tell her to leave . I have no interest in seeing her . Before the housekeeper could respond , the dining room doors swung open , and Allison stepped inside , the scent of roses announcing her presence . She entered the room with her usual poise , every step graceful . Her gaze swept across the room , briefly pausing on Emma before settling on David . Just moments ago , he had been smiling and joking , but now his expression had frozen , his eyes fixed on Allison . Turning a blind eye to the sudden tension that had fallen over the room , Allison spoke in her sickly sweet voice . Im sorry for dropping by without notice , but I felt it was necessary to speak with you , Grandfather . The grandfathers face darkened the moment he saw her . His voice was sharp , leaving no room for argument . You are not welcome here and you have no right to call me that . You lost that privilege the day you walked out on this family . If you have even an ounce of dignity left , you would not have returned . Leave this house immediately with your false sentiments ! Allisons composure faltered , her cheeks flushing with embarrassment . She cast a quick glance at David , her eyes brimming with unshed tears . I know youre angry , and you have every right to be . But I didnt come here to cause trouble . I came to make amends . The grandfather scoffed . Amends ? Spare me your false feelings . Youve done enough damage . Now leave before you disgrace yourself further . 2/3 +25 BONUS A Night to Remeinber Tears welled up in her eyes as her hands trembled , but she clasped them together , and took a deep breath before speaking . Grandpa , she began , her voice quivering , I understand if you think poorly of me for leaving so abruptly . But I felt it was the right thing to do . I knew of Emmas feelings for David . I didnt want to be the obstacle in their path to happiness . So , I made the difficult decision to step aside , hoping it would allow them to be together . Emma stared at her , shocked by her claims . She quickly turned her attention to David and Grandpa , searching their faces for any sign that they believed her . The last thing she wanted was for Grandpa to complain about her . Davids brow furrowed , his lips pressed into a thin line . He remained impassive , his gaze fixed on Allison while Grandpa scoffed , then pointed at her , Youre a liar ; Do you think any of us is going to believe your fake acts ? Allison looked back at David , her expression heartbreakingly vulnerable . I … she hesitated and then turned and fled the room , her sobs echoing in the hallway . David stood abruptly , his chair scraping against the floor . For a moment , he looked torn , his gaze shifting between the door and Emma . Then , as if unable to help himself , he moved to follow Allison . David , sit down , the grandfather commanded , his voice icy . David hesitated , his fists clenching at his sides . Emma watched in disbelief as the two men locked eyes , the atmosphere tense . Her heart ached as she realized where Davids loyalty truly lay . The standoff was broken by a servant rushing into the room . Miss Allison has collapsed outside ! Shes had an asthma attack ! All of them froze for a moment , the air thick with shock . Then , without hesitation , David turned on his heel and rushed toward the doorway . David , dont you dare ! Grandpa shouted after him in anger . Dont walk out on your family for her ! But David didnt stop . Emma watched , her heart shattering , as he ignored his grandfathers words and disappeared through the doorway.