Chapter 12 Bethany sneered , " I never believed in blind favoritism . Winona spoiled Estelle so much , there had to be a reason . We just have to figure out what it is - like how did she find Estelle back then ? Where did she take Estelle abroad ? And how did she get Estelle to copy Mel so well ? " If Estelle didn't look so much like Melanie , Bethany would've thought her was fake from the start . Melanie grew up right under her nose , so Bethany knew her temper and habits best . But then Winona took " Melanie " abroad without a word . When she came back , she wasn't that close to Bethany . Distant , yes - but some of her habits hadn't changed ... Bethany had always thought maybe a few years overseas had just made Melanie a little distant . Until it was found out that Estelle wasn't Alberto's real daughter . It happened suddenly . It was found during the physical exam . The Rasmussen family had a physical every year , and the blood types had always matched - until a few months ago . Estelle's physical showed her blood type was O. But Alberto was type A , and Winona was AB . There was no way their child could have type O report blood . Bethany went straight to the hospital to confirm it - Estelle really was type O. As for the old report showing AB , the answer was simple : someone had likely tampered with it . The hospital was investigating , but they still hadn't found any results . Since then , Bethany finally figured out something she hadn't understood for years . Why did " Melanie " grow distant after coming back from abroad ? Turns out , she was totally fake. But Winona said , the two kids were switched . That was really funny . If she was switched at birth , how did she live with Melanie for so many years ? Was everything before Melanie turned six just a dream ? Then Melanie was found and brought back . The girl she had loved since childhood stood in front of her . Only then did she realize ... something was different . That was blood . That was family . No one could fake or replace it . Winona's explanation was full of holes , and the way she defended Estelle made Bethany more suspicious . She thought Estelle might be Winona's child with someone else . So , she secretly did a paternity test for them . The result showed Estelle wasn't Winona's daughter . Now , the only way to find out what Winona really wants is to find Estelle's real parents . 09:29 5.5 % < Chapter 12 Menu " You didn't have to worry . " The key person noticed Bethany's anger and said , " I'll keep an eye on all these things myself , so just relax . " Bethany calmed down a lot , " Keep an eye on Winona lately . Estelle and Warren's marriage didn't work out , and I'm worried she might do something to Mel again . " " Okay " the Fulton's villa . Nikolas and Araceli and Warren's parents walked into the villa with cold faces . Warren followed behind with the same gloomy look on his face . Georgia Carrillo glanced back at Warren , couldn't keep a straight face anymore , and burst out laughing . " Honey, I really regret not taking a picture of your son's priceless look at the engagement party . " Georgia gave Warren a half - smile . " With that poker face , I'm starting to think I had twins , and the useless one in front of Melanie is the other son I've been hiding . " Warren glanced at her , walked straight to the sofa and sat down , crossed his legs , and said slowly , " You don't want the perfume anymore ? " The smile on Georgia's lips froze right away . Then she grabbed Fabian Fulton's arm and said sweetly , " Honey , look at him ! " Fabian patted her hand , eyes full of affection , " If he dares not buy it for you , I'll beat him up . " " Beat me up ? " Warren curled his lips . " Dad , you sure you could take me ? " Fabian's face froze , a bit awkward , " What ? You think you can actually hit your old man ? " " Don't dare ! " Warren stayed calm . " But whether we could get Mr. Bacchus's private brew , who knows . " Fabian , " ... " This damn kid . As annoying as ever . He retired in his early fifties . With nothing to do , drinking had become a hobby . Mr. Bacchus was a well - known winemaker in the country . The price couldn't compete with those famous foreign wines , but it tasted really good . Warren had gotten him two bottles before . He'd treasured them , drinking just a little each day , but still finished them recently . It had taken a lot of effort to get Warren to promise more , and now the kid was using it to bargain . Araceli and Nikolas rolled their eyes the moment they saw Warren's face . No one knew who this kid took after . He was always so cold , like someone owed him a million bucks . If he had always been like this , fine . But the way he acted so cheap and fawning in front of Melanie , they really wondered , did he only swap souls when facing Melanie ? Araceli walked over and kicked Warren on the leg , " Sit up . " After she finished speaking , she sat next to Warren and asked , " What's going on between you and that Melanie ? " 09:29 5.5 % < Chapter 12 " My girlfriend . " Warren smiled when Melanie was mentioned . Araceli just couldn't bear to look . Georgia even turned her head away , out of sight , out of mind . So she wouldn't get too upset . Menu " Why didn't you bring your girlfriend home earlier ? You just had to let things get out of hand . Good thing I get along with Bethany , otherwise I wouldn't even know how to explain this . " Araceli slapped Warren in frustration . " What have you been doing all day ? " Warren sat up straight , looking serious , and said , " I need to remind you , you set up an engagement for me without my permission , and that violated my legal rights ... " " Hey , you little bastard . " Warren hadn't even finished talking when Araceli slapped him . " What ? You wanna send me to jail or something ? " " For those with serious cases , three years in prison . " Warren stated the fact calmly . Araceli glared at him , " It's your fault . You're never home , your phone is just for show , never pick up no matter how many times I call . If you ever came back even once , I wouldn't have rushed to settle things with Estelle . " Araceli sighed , " But now the problem is , it's probably hard for you to marry Melanie . Seeing her today , she didn't plan to be with you . And Bethany cares about Melanie like she's her own eyes . From the way she talked , she didn't want to let Melanie marry you either . " Araceli was worried , but she felt proud . Warren always looked down on people , never respected anyone . Now finally someone was able to handle him , but ironically , that person didn't care about him . Warren shot her a look , " You made my wife leave , you go get her back for me . " Araceli was mad , " What ? What do you mean I made her leave ? " " You kept forcing girls on me , of course she thinks I'm cheating . " Warren got a headache just thinking about it . He was randomly accused of cheating , and he didn't even have a chance to explain . Melanie totally ignored him . The harder he chased , the harder she hit . But he just couldn't hit back . " I ..., " Araceli couldn't find the words for a moment . It seemed like she really messed things up . Warren stood up , " You guys go figure out a way to get my wife back . If you can't get her back , don't even think about getting anything you want . "