" Dexter . " 3/3 Dexter +25 BONUS Dexter He stood in his doorway with a cocky grin and despite everything that he had done to me and all of the sh * t he talked , butterflies fluttered in my stomach . I took a deep breath and gave him a side - hug . He took it a bit further and pecked my cheek and then ushered me inside , placing his hand on my lower back . I was no stranger to Dexter's home . I had been here countless times but this time felt a little uncomfortable . Probably because I came for a favor and knew that the price was going to make me feel like crap . He took us upstairs to his room and glanced back at me . " You parked away from the house , right ? " It was our rule for when I visited in case Alicia was ' cruising by ' and happened to see my car in his driveway . " Yeah . I did . " I sat down on his bed and watched as he closed his bedroom door and turned to me with his signature smirk . " I was surprised when you called . " " I know . It's been a bit . " " Yeah . He walkes over to me and took my face in his hands and kissed me . Compared to James , Dexter was rough , his tongue probing my mouth like it owned the place . I pulled back and pressed my hand on his chest . " Slow down, cowboy . " I pressed my lips together , fighting the urge to wipe my mouth . He grinned and climbed over me on his bed , pushing my thighs apart to lay in between my legs . I could feel his erection against my center and even though this sort of felt wrong , I felt my face heat up . He leaned over me , pushing my hair aside and stared at my neck . " Are you ever going to tell me who your mystery man is ? " He pressed his lips against my neck , where I knew James had left a hickey . " Nope . But it seems you've gotten used to the idea of it . " I stifled a moan as he palmed my chest and continued to suck and nip at my throat . He didn't seem to be worried about leaving a mark anymore . He moved his hand under my shirt and pulled at my bra hastily . I couldn't help but compare him to James . James was always quick with it , but he didn't see to fumble as much as Dexter . " Nope . Just biding my time until you f * ck up and reveal who he is . I'll kick his a * s for trying to take my girl and then make fun of him for leaving you wanting me . " I almost rolled my eyes . He ground his hips against my center and I couldn't help but moan at the sensation . It felt good , but the guilt was beginning to eat at me . I knew James and I weren't a thing , but being with another guy just felt wrong . I wondered if he had felt the same when he had kissed Pink Streak . " I'm not your girl . Alicia is . " I panted as he kissed his way down my chest over my shirt . He sat up and took his shirt off , showing his golden abs and a line of dark hair leading from underneath his belly button to under his basketball shorts . I was only human . I stared at him and he grinned . " Alicia doesn't matter right now . Are you finally going to let me in ? " I took a deep breath and watched as he began unbuttoning my shorts and pulling them down . I was such a sl * t . I lifted by legs to help him pulled them off and his grin widened . He pressed his hand over my mound and rubbed 1/2 Dexter +25 BONUS me through my panties . I could feel myself getting so wet . I had dreamed about this for a long time and even though it was happening , a small part of me still felt sh * tty . He continued to rub me as he leaned down and kissed me , then sat up again . " You want to suck my c * ck , baby ? " He pulled his d * ck out of his shorts and stroked himself , looking down at my face with a devilish grin . " Okay . " I sat up and he laid down where I was at . He continued to stroke himself as I pulled my hair back into a ponytail . This was where it always stopped . He would make me give him head and then he would make the excuse of not liking to ' taste himself ' so that I wouldn't kiss him anymore . I placed my mouth over the tip , tasting his precum when his bedroom door opened . " Hey Dex ! Do you still have that- " I pulled away quickly and hid my burning face in my hands . Michael stood at the open door staring at me , his mouth open . " Dude ! Get the f * ck out ! I've told you to start f * cking knocking ! " Dexter threw a pillow at the door and Michael ducked out quickly , but not before shaking his head in disappointment . I felt tears sting in my eyes as I thought about him telling James that I was here . I stood up quickly and threw my shorts back on , fixing my shirt back in place and feeling like the biggest piece of sh * t in the world . " Hey , it's okay . We can lock the door . What are you doing ? " " I forgot that I have to get that stuff to my mom . Can you still get it , or .. ? " Dexter sighed , tucking himself back into his shorts and nodded . " Yeah . Give me a minute and we can go . " I nodded and waited until he pulled his shirt back on and grabbed his wallet and keys . " Can I come over after ? " " Chloe is coming by . " " What time ? " I looked at my phone and looked back up at him . " In like half an hour . " " I won't take but five minutes and I'll be gone before she gets there . " I swallowed back the bile in my throat and shrugged . " We'll see how long this takes . " He nodded and opened his bedroom door . He nodded at someone just outside and then began walking down the hall . I walked out and both James and Michael were standing in Michael's bedroom doorway , looking at me . I ducked my head as I walked out and felt tears sting the corners of my eyes . I didn't even see his reaction . But I knew that he would probably be upset . I was upset . Today's Bonus Offer