hapter 31 Back then Olivia wasn't yet called Olivia Sutton ; she was Olivia Winters . Her father , Carlos , had every terrible habit a man could have : heavy drinking , gambling , chasing prostitutes , and violence . Yet Carlos was also a hypocrite who knew how to hide himself , so well that for many years no one saw his true face . For a long time , Olivia believed every father in the world was like that . Emilia had a proud spirit and refused to beg her parents for help or let outsiders know she'd married the wrong man . And they lived isolated and unsupported . Fortunately , in the poor neighborhood where they lived , people's lives were roughly the same- Olivia didn't have it well , but nobody else was living happily either . When people called her a little messy or a poor beggar , Olivia fired back by mocking them as Fatherless bastards . Their daily fights left wounds on both sides . Then one day Olivia saw Natasha - the little cousin in a floral dress , clean and fair and pretty . It turned out such lives existed : parents who loved you , brothers who doted on you , carefree days so innocent they made someone else angry . The first time they met , Olivia didn't even dare touch her , afraid she'd soil Natasha's expensive clothes . But Natasha didn't mind at all ; she bounded over cheerfully , hugged Olivia , and shared bright candies and toys Olivia had never seen before . Olivia hated Natasha . ' I hate her , ' she thought . ' She shone so brightly that I exposed every bit of my lowliness and darkness . Worse, since Natasha's family arrived , Emilia had only grown sadder and more withdrawn . And Carlos's beatings of her got worse . Then one day Emilia told Olivia the life Natasha had was supposed to have been hers . Andrew was originally supposed to be Emilia's fiancé , but he fell for Madeline instead and became engaged to her . Tricked by Carlos in a fit of rage , Emilia fell into an abyss from which she couldn't climb out . If the accident back then hadn't happened , Emilia would have been Andrew's wife , and Olivia would have lived like a princess just like Natasha . 1/4 E 4:33 pm P 22 . Chapter 31 120 vouchers Olivia was too young to understand then . Although she was jealous , she didn't know how deep that wrong turn would cut . Until one night , after Carlos got drunk and beat Emilia again , Olivia tried to shield her and was beaten bloody herself . In the chaos , Emilia protected her and told her to run to the Clarks for help . Olivia staggered to the Clark house , bedraggled and terrified , only to find Andrew and Madeline smiling as they called the kids in for dinner . Natasha , upset because her brother had picked her flower , was being fussed over by Thomas and Noel . Seeing Natasha fussed over while Olivia lay bleeding , at death's door , was absurd to Olivia . Olivia slunk around like a rat in a gutter , bitterly jealous of Natasha's good fortune . When Olivia's fresh wounds stung and her brother finally soothed Natasha with candy , Olivia limped away in tears . Seeing her , the Clark couple were furious . Though it had been a fated accident and they hadn't meant to hurt Emilia , the situation was awkward . Once they learned how badly Emilia had suffered , Andrew and Madeline felt guilty . They acted decisively : they forced Carlos to divorce Emilia , had him arrested , and gave Emilia enough money to get through the worst of it . After Emilia returned home , the first thing she did was change Olivia's surname - to Olivia Sutton -making it clear she was Emilia's daughter . Life back at Sutton house was much better . After that , visits and contact with Madeline's family increased . Olivia had quietly told Emilia she didn't like going to Madeline's house and didn't like Natasha . Those happy scenes made her feel even smaller . Emilia would just pat her head and say with meaning that what Natasha had , Olivia would have too . In truth , Emilia had been saying a lot of things like farewells before the accident . Late at night Olivia would sometimes see Emilia talking to herself , saying that her daughter would have a better life than Natasha , and that Madeline's debts would all be repaid . That version of Emilia was nothing like the gentle woman Olivia usually knew . Still , Olivia never doubted - Emilia loved her . Emilia had given everything to her . 2/4 4:33 pm Chapter 31 E20 vouchers Looking at Natasha - the cousin who had once been unreachable - Olivia asked , with a light laugh , " Do you think I stole your family ? " Olivia smiled thinly . " But it was mine to begin with . I just took back what should have been mine . " Natasha's eyes flickered . " What do you mean ? " Olivia didn't answer directly . " We're sisters , but our mothers ' lives ended up in completely different . places . That's fine . Our gap will only grow . " Olivia watched the Clark brothers come down from the cemetery path one by one . " Natasha , you're lucky . In the end Grandma favored you too . Do you know what Grandma said before she died ? " Through the curtain of rain she smiled , then slowly said three words , " Help ... help ... me . " Instantly , Natasha's eyes blazed red . She lunged forward and grabbed Olivia by her throat . " You killed Grandma ." Olivia gasped for breath but still smiled . " Me ? No , no . At most I didn't save her . So what ? Why should the same blood get special treatment ? She always puts you first . Why ? Because of you - if you hadn't followed Grandma everywhere , if you hadn't clung to her , she might still be alive . " " Grandma cared about you too . After you returned back , Carlos kept bothering you , and she protected you . Later it was only because my parents favored you that she paid attention to me a bit more , " Natasha said , her voice full of hatred . Olivia shot back , " And so what ? From the day my name changed , I decided no one would be allowed to treat us differently . " Natasha felt like she might choke . Tears mixed with the rain . " Natasha ! " Noel sprang forward and shoved Natasha away ; her body crashed hard into Emilia's gravestone . Thomas put down his umbrella and scooped Olivia from the ground without even looking at Natasha , hurrying them away . Noel glanced at Thomas walking off with Olivia , then at Natasha's pained , drawn face . After a moment's hesitation he followed , holding the umbrella over Thomas and Olivia and getting half soaked himself . From her place in the rain , Olivia looked back at Natasha standing alone like a small sapling in a storm and felt a quiet , terrible satisfaction at the life's reversal . The little girl who used to hide in the dark and watch other people's happiness was no longer the abandoned one . 3/4 4:33 pm PS Chapter 31 & & ' Mom , you must be so pleased now , Olivia thought with a silent smile . ***** 20 vouchers Down at the cemetery gate , the Clark couple hurried to open the car doors . " Where's Natasha ? " Andrew asked . Thomas ' face was cold . " Don't worry about her . Let her stay and think . " Madeline's expression softened , but when Olivia gave a little cry of pain they hardened their faces . Then Madeline said , " Come on . We'll take her to the hospital ." Andrew looked up at the thin , lonely figure half - hidden by the rain and sighed . " Let's go . " Two cars sped away through the rain .